Human shields. When humanitarian law turns against war victims
Neve Gordon & Nicola Perugini
Neve Gordon is a professor of human rights law at Queen Mary University of London and the Vice President of the British Society for Middle East Studies. He is the author of Israel’s Occupation (University of California Press 2008). and the co-author of The Human Right to Dominate (Oxford University Press 2015) and Human Shields. A History of People in the Line of Fire (University of California Press 2020). Neve Gordon has been a member at the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton, and a visiting scholar at the University of California, Berkeley, Brown University, the University of Michigan, and SOAS, and is currently a board member of the International State Crime Initiative.
Nicola Perugini teaches international politics at University of Edimburg. His research focuses mainly on the politics of international law, human rights, and violence. He is the co-author of The Human Right to Dominate (Oxford University Press 2015), Morbid Symptoms (Sharjah Biennial 13, 2017), and Human Shields. A History of People in the Line of Fire (University of California Press 2020). Nicola Perugini has published articles on war and the ethics of violence; the politics of human rights, humanitarianism, and international law; humanitarianism's visual cultures; war and embedded anthropology; refugees and asylum seekers; law, space and colonialism; settler-colonialism.
On Thursday June 12, 2025, the Crash team was delighted to welcome Neve Gordon and Nicola Perugini, for a conference entitled " Human shields. When humanitarian law turns against war victims". This meeting was prepared and moderated by Fabrice Weissman and Hakim Chkam.
00:38 Presentation
03:27 Introduction
12:18 Human shields, attacks on hospitals, and the Gaza abyss
33:44 The Norm, the Law and the Protection of Hospitals in War Zones
57:05 Why should we still believe in the normative power of law in war situations?
01:01:36 Question 1: Wouldn’t social pressure be more effective than a legal ban?
01:11:29 Question 2: To what extent does the counterterrorism doctrine challenge the principles of distinction established by the Geneva Conventions?
01:21:37 Question 3: To what extent is the US-influenced approach of 'algorithmic governmentality' being applied in Gaza?
01:25:23 Question 4: What can we realistically expect from a ban, given that states can always find ways to circumvent legal provisions?
01:33:04 Question 5: How relevant is the comparison with the ban on landmines?
“Even war has rules”. This is the slogan brandished by MSF, the United Nations and the ICRC to protest against the bombing of health facilities and the massacre of civilians in Gaza and in many other conflicts. “Yes, war has rules”, retorts the Israeli army, but in this case it's Hamas that's violating them by using hospitals and the population as “human shields”. As such, the Israeli armed forces are not guilty of any crime in causing the “accidental” death of civilians, wounded and health workers in its fight against the perpetrators of the October 7 atrocities.
While not new, this line of reasoning is taken to extremes by the Israeli government, whose propaganda invokes international humanitarian law to justify its genocidal violence against the Palestinian population. As Neve Gordon and Nicola Perugini point out, international humanitarian law (IHL) does not offer unconditional protection to health facilities and non-combatants, especially when they are described as “human shields”. The latter can then be bombed, provided that “military necessity” justifies it and that “precautions” have been taken to avoid collateral casualties “excessive in relation to the military advantage anticipated”.
Under these conditions, isn't calling for respect for international humanitarian law to protest against the bombing of hospitals and civilians counter-productive? In practice, is IHL not the ally of the most powerful states, authorizing war violence against unarmed populations? To which extent does the consent of European states to the reversal of IHL against war victims in Gaza constitutes a turning point? How can we strengthen the normative framework protecting hospitals and civilians in conflicts, and increase the political cost of mass violence?
These are the questions we discussed on Thursday June 12 from 6.30pm with Neve Gordon and Nicola Perugini. Neve Gordon is former director of Physicians for Human Rights. He teaches international law at Queen Mary University of London. Nicola Perugini is Professor of International Relations at Edinburgh University. Both published in 2020: Human Shields. A History of People in the Line of Fire (University of California Press 2020).
References:
- Neve Gordon , Nicola Perugini, ‘Hospital Shields’ and the Limits of International Law Free, in European Journal of International Law, Volume 30, Issue 2, May 2019, Pages 439–463: https://academic.oup.com/ejil/article/30/2/439/5536724
- Neve Gordon , Nicola Perugini, Human Shields. A History of People in the Line of Fire (University of California Press 2020)
- Neve Gordon , Nicola Perugini, A Legal Justification for Genocide? July 17, 2024? https://jewishcurrents.org/human-shields-gaza-israel-a-legal-justification-for-genocide
To cite this content :
Neve Gordon, Nicola Perugini, “Human shields. When humanitarian law turns against war victims”, 12 juin 2025, URL : https://msf-crash.org/en/conferences-debates/human-shields-when-humanitarian-law-turns-against-war-victims
If you would like to comment on this article, you can find us on social media or contact us here:
Contribute
MSF
Analysis
Préface à l'ouvrage "Le Livre noir de Gaza"
10/07/2024Le Livre noir de Gaza est un ouvrage paru le 4 octobre 2024 aux Éditions du Seuil. Il recense autant que possible les faits qu’ont pu établir les ONG internationales, palestiniennes et israéliennes, depuis le début de la guerre. Il est construit à partir de leurs rapports, d’enquêtes d’experts et d’articles de presse, sélectionnés et introduits par la spécialiste du Moyen-Orient Agnès Levallois, avec les contributions inédites de consultants indépendants et responsables d’ONG. La préface a été rédigée par Rony Brauman.
Conference
Ukraine-Gaza, exchange of views
12/03/2024 - 06:30 PM 08:30 PMOn Tuesday, December 3, 2024, the Crash team was pleased to welcome Julia Grignon, Jean-François Corty and Rony Brauman for a conference-debate to mark the publication of the latest issue of Alternatives Humanitaires magazine: “Ukraine-Gaza, cross-perspectives”, in which humanitarian practitioners and observers share their analyses.
Interview
Rony Brauman : « Nous sommes, à Gaza, face à une situation génocidaire »
11/08/2024Guerres au Proche-Orient, putschs au Sahel, reflux démocratique global… Celui qui présida Médecins sans frontières de 1982 à 1994 porte un regard pessimiste sur le devenir du monde. Un entretien de Jeune Afrique.
Past events
Conference
Clinical trials, between science and financial and academic interests
10/08/2020 - 06:00 PM 08:00 PMThe Crash team was delighted to welcome Pierre Chirac, pharmacist and editor of the magazine Prescrire, for a conference on his analysis of the pharmaceutical industry's influence strategies and the special interests of university hospital researchers, their consequences on the reliability of drug information and the means now required to rectify a harmful situation. This meetting was prepared and moderated by Rony Brauman.
Conference
Territories: the illusion of identity
12/16/2019 - 06:00 PM 08:00 PMCan we talk about the specificities of the Middle East, Iran or the Mediterranean without reducing these territories to a culture or religion? On December 16, 2019, the CRASH team organised a conference-debate with Jean-François Bayart, a French political scientist who has devoted his work to the sociology of the State and identity illusions. This meeting, prepared with Claudine Vidal, was moderated by Elba Rahmouni.
Charles Habib
Conference
Screening - debate / La Ville Monde
11/07/2019 - 06:30 PM 08:30 PMMédecins Sans Frontières and Crash were pleased to invite you to a screening, followed by a debate, of the documentary film "La Ville Monde", directed by Antarès Bassis and produced by Les films du Balibari. The film, of which MSF is a partner, traces the trajectory of the La Linière camp in Grande-Synthe from its opening in March 2016 to the fire that destroyed it in April 2017. This event was prepared and moderated by Michaël Neuman.
Conference
Motivations for mass violence: different interpretations
10/03/2019 - 06:00 PM 08:00 PMWhat turns ordinary men into killers? The CRASH team invited you to a conference – debate with the sociologist and historian, Nicolas Mariot. This meeting, prepared with Claudine Vidal, was moderated by Elba Rahmouni.
Conference
Third-Worldism and Sans-Frontiérisme 1954-1988
04/11/2019 - 06:30 PM 08:30 PMEleanor Davey, historian of ideas and humanitarianism, senior lecturer at the Humanitarian and Conflict Research Institute, University of Manchester, discusses her book, Idealism Beyond Borders. The French Revolutionary Left and the Rise of Humanitarianism, 1954-1988, devoted to the intellectual history of sans-frontiérisme and Third-Worldism, in France, from the Algerian war to the early years of Médecins Sans Frontières. This conference was prepared and moderated by Michaël Neuman.
Eddy Van Wessel
Conference
Extreme violence: investigate, rescue, judge. Syria, Rwanda, Democratic Republic of Congo
03/20/2019 - 02:00 PM 03/22/2019 - 05:00 PMTheaters of war, genocide, mass crimes, Syria, Rwanda and the Democratic Republic of Congo are at the heart of the international symposium organized by the platform L’humanitaire dans la globalisation of the Fondation Maison des sciences de l’homme (FMSH) and the Centre de Réflexion sur l'Action et les Savoirs Humanitaires (CRASH) of Médecins Sans Frontières. This symposium is part of the commemoration by these two institutions of the 25 years of the genocide of Rwandan Tutsis.